This week is the seven hundred and tenth anniversary of the birth, life, reign and death of King John I of France in 1316.
He was the son of King Louis X and Queen Clémence of Hungary. King Louis, who had succeeded his father King Philip IV in November 1314, had died five months earlier on June 5th, aged 26 and apparently as a consequence of over indulgence in chilled wine after a game of real tennis - he is the first named player of the game. I have a post about him at King Louis X . A regency had ensued headed by the late King’s next brother, Philip, Count of Poitiers, as the realm awaited the birth of a male or female heir.
The effigy at St Denisdated to 1327
Image: Genevra Kornbluth on Pinterest
There was a female candidate in Jeanne, born in 1312 to King Louis and his first wife, Margaret of Burgundy - herself a granddaughter through her mother of St Louis. That was two years before the Tour de Nesle affair brought scandal and uncertainty to the French royal house. At first King Louis doubted the legitimacy of his daughter, but on his deathbed in 1316 affirmed it. Eventually after the death without male heirs of her two patrilineal uncles she succeeded them on her grandmother’s throne as Queen Jeanne II of Navarre in 1328, and died in 1349.
Margaret of Burgundy was imprisoned at Chateau Gaillard and conveniently died in late April 1315 and her widower married Clémence - or Clemencia - of Hungary in the following August and was speedily crowned as Queen Consort.
Effigy from the church of the Jacobins, moved to St Denis in 1816
Image: Wikipedia
Despite her territorial designation - her father was an unsuccessful claimant to the Hungarian crown - Clemence was a member of the extended Capetian family. Her great grandfather, the youngest brother of St Louis and Count of Anjou had established himself as King of Sicily in 1266, and she was also the niece by marriage of King Philip IV’s brother Charles Count of Valois. Following their marriage King Louis and Queen Clémence went on pilgrimage to the shrine of the head of St John the Baptist at Amiens Cathedral, and presumably had seen the Queen’s pregnancy as an answer to the Baptist’s intercession.
On November 15th the widowed Queen gave birth to a
son who was given the name John, but who died in November 20th and was buried at St Denis alongside his father.

The effigy of King John I at St Denis
Image: Pinterest
Being born as King is a distinction he shares with very few other monarchs, but including King Ladislas V of Hungary in the fifteenth century and King Alfonso XIII of Spain in the nineteenth century.
The rapid demise of King John led at the time to accusations of foul play. Countess Mahaut of Artois, mother-in-law of the Count of Poitiers was alleged to have killed the baby with a needle inserted into his brain. Druon in his novels about the later Capetians has her poisoning the infant, but integrates that with a story that emerged later in the century that the royal child was spirited away and a substitute killed and buried at St Denis. The “real” monarch then reappeared in the 1330s seeking the French crown. Later medieval Europe had a number of such claimants in Norway, England, Denmark and Portugal.
King John I had the shortest reign of any French monarch, unless the claim that King Louis XIX reigned for twenty minutes during the July Revolution in 1830 is accepted. I would be inclined to view that as a situation of duress, and that, in consequence of the Orleanist usurpation King Charles X remained the legitimate monarch until his death in 1836 and that he was then succeeded by King Louis XIX until his death in 1844 and the undoubted inheritance at that point of King Henri V. Wikipedia makes the same point in Louis Antoine, Duke of Angoulême
The death of King John was to be of real significance. For the first time since the election of Hugh Capet in 987 the succession did not pass from father to eldest surviving son. This change was not that obvious if Jeanne was ruled out as both female and possibly illegitimate, although she did become Queen Jeanne II of Navarre in 1328 following the death of her other paternal uncle, King Charles IV.
The acceptance by the political elite of her uncle the Count of Poitiers as King Philip V rather than Jeanne
took France towards the Salic law, although that was not fully defined until the late fourteenth century.
took France towards the Salic law, although that was not fully defined until the late fourteenth century.
There is a Wikipedia biography of King Philip V - the Tall - at Philip V of France
Both he and his brother and successor King Charles IV sought to produce a male heir, but only had daughters, who were now seen as ineligible for the throne. In 1328 the French crown passed to their cousin Philip, Count of Valois who became King Philip VI. This by-passed the arguable claim by proximity of blood of the son of the sister of Kings Louis, Philip and Charles. That was the formidable Queen Isabella, widow ( probably or possibly ) of King Edward II and mother of King Edward III. Possessing a claim to the French crown was a very useful weapon in the young King of England’s diplomatic and military armoury as he sought to disentangle the constraints on his position in both England and Gascony that arose from the implicit alliance of France and Scotland. The argument that the Hundred Years War lasted two centuries and began in 1292 rather than 1337 is a good one. As to when the wars ended maybe we should look to King George III agreeing not to use the title King of France in the Treaty of Amiens in 1802…

The effigies of King Philip V, Queen Jeanne of Evreux, third wife of King Charles IV, and of King Charles IV as now displayed at St Denis
Image: Pinterest-Basilique de St Denis
For more about these fascinating events in France there are now good history books available and, for really pacy reading, Maurice Druon’s six Accursed Kings novels and the 1973 ORTF television series - not the later remake.



No comments:
Post a Comment