Once I was a clever boy learning the arts of Oxford... is a quotation from the verses written by Bishop Richard Fleming (c.1385-1431) for his tomb in Lincoln Cathedral. Fleming, the founder of Lincoln College in Oxford, is the subject of my research for a D. Phil., and, like me, a son of the West Riding. I have remarked in the past that I have a deeply meaningful on-going relationship with a dead fifteenth century bishop... it was Fleming who, in effect, enabled me to come to Oxford and to learn its arts, and for that I am immensely grateful.


Friday, 20 November 2026

St Edmund - life and death in art


Today is the feast of St Edmund, the King of East Anglia martyrs in 869-870 by the Danish invaders.
In the central and later medieval centuries he was not just a patron saint of East Anglia but, alongside St Edward the Confessor, seen as a patron of England until St George took the foremost place in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries. They nevertheless remained national patrons, especially of the monarchy and its institutions. St Edmund was also seen in that role in respect of the Lordship of Ireland- and hence, no doubt, the popularity of the Irish version of his name, Eamon.

The centre of his cult and his burial place and shrine was the immensely important Benedictine abbey of Bury Edmunds.


St Edmund crowned by Angels.
A detail from the Passio Sancti Eadmundi produced at Bury St Edmunds in or about 1130

Image: Wikimedia Commons. 

Wikipedia has a detailed presentation of what can be definitely known about his life and offers an exploration of the development of the narrative of his martyrdom  , together with other aspects of devotion to him. This can be accessed at Edmund the Martyr

Part of the development of his cultus was the writing of hagiographical accounts and their subsequent transmission and adaptation. With St Edmund the defining moment was the composition by Abbo of Fleury of the Passio Sancti Eadmundi for the abbey at Ramsey in about 986, and this text was copied and supplemented over the following years. In about 1130 the abbey at Bury commissioned or produced a sumptuously illustrated version which is now at the Morgan Library and Museum (formerly the Pierpont Morgan Library) in New York. There website has a section devoted to all the illuminations which is at Miscellany on the life of St. Edmund - Medieval & Renaissance Manuscripts Online - The Morgan Library & Museum

This is an outstanding example of early twelfth century English art in both draughtsmanship and painting as can be seen in the following examples:


St Edmund is crowned as King of East Anglia

Image: Facebook 


Edmund is led to his martyrdom.  


The Martyrdom of St Edmund

Image: Wikipedia 

 

St Edmund is beheaded and his head thrown into a wood

Image: Wikipedia 


His head is recovered - note the wolf in the foreground 
 
Image: St Mark’s Church, Southend


The vision of St Edmund frightens King Sweyn of Denmark to death at Gainsborough in 1013

 Image: Medieval History Buff

More than just their visual impact, with their mix of piety,  drama, charm and naïveté, they are an indicator of the skills employed in the use of colour in the early twelfth century, and over a wider timescale. Those who claim romanesque churches were gaudy should look at manuscripts such as this. The same applies to those who might consider elite costume and vestments overly colourful - and also to those today who envisage a medieval world that was dull, grey, mud-coloured and mud-bound. The Morgan manuscript may be a very  
    special commission, but those who produced it were not detached from the world

Looking at it one inevitably wonders just how many similar works were lost in the sixteenth century. That point also applies to the surviving fragments of the abbey at Bury St Edmunds, tantalising in their gaunt rubble core fragments, yet with sufficient remaining to begin to recreate in the mind, and through artistic skill and image technology what was probably once there.


A reconstruction of the abbey church as built in the eleventh and twelfth centuries 

Image: abbeyofstedmund.org.uk


The west front as it may have appeared after completion by Abbot Samson in the thirteenth century and before the collapse of the central west tower in 1430-31 and its subsequent rebuilding

Image: English Heritage 


A reconstructed of the east end, together with King Cnut’s circular church, as they might have appeared at the beginning of the twelfth century 

Image: English Heritage

There is more about theses reconstruction images and the appearance of the great church at Abbey of St Edmund Heritage Partnership - Imagining the past

May St Edmund pray for us all

Wednesday, 18 November 2026

The life and death of King John I of France


This article is a revised version of one I posted a decade ago, which I have updated with additional illustrations and more background and interpretive material.


This week is the seven hundred and tenth anniversary of the birth, life, reign and death of King John I of France in 1316.

He was the son of King Louis X and Queen Clémence of Hungary. King Louis, who had succeeded his father King Philip IV in November 1314, had died five months earlier on June 5th, aged 26 and apparently as a consequence of over indulgence in chilled wine after a game of real tennis - he is the first named player of the game. I have a post about him at King Louis X . A regency had ensued headed by the late King’s next brother, Philip, Count of Poitiers, as the realm awaited the birth of a male or female heir.


King Louis X

The effigy at St Denisdated to 1327

Image: Genevra Kornbluth on Pinterest 

There was a female candidate in Jeanne, born in 1312 to King Louis and his first wife, Margaret of Burgundy - herself a granddaughter through her mother of St Louis. That was two years before the Tour de Nesle affair brought scandal and uncertainty to the French royal house. At first King Louis doubted the legitimacy of his daughter, but on his deathbed in 1316 affirmed it. Eventually after the death without male heirs of her two patrilineal uncles she succeeded them on her grandmother’s throne as Queen Jeanne II of Navarre in 1328, and died in 1349. 


Queen Jeanne II of Navarre

Effigy at St Denis 

Image: Wikipedia 

Margaret of Burgundy was imprisoned at Chateau Gaillard and conveniently died in late April 1315 and her widower married Clémence - or Clemencia - of Hungary in the following August and was speedily crowned as Queen Consort.


Queen Clémence 

Effigy from the church of the Jacobins, moved to St Denis in 1816
  
Image: Wikipedia 

Despite her territorial designation - her father was an unsuccessful claimant to the Hungarian crown - Clemence was a member of the extended Capetian family. Her great grandfather, the youngest brother of St Louis and Count of Anjou had established himself as King of Sicily in 1266, and she was also the niece by marriage of King Philip IV’s brother Charles Count of Valois. Following their marriage King Louis and Queen Clémence went on pilgrimage to the shrine of the head of St John the Baptist at Amiens Cathedral, and presumably had seen the Queen’s pregnancy as an answer to the Baptist’s intercession.

On November 15th the widowed Queen gave birth to a 
son who was given the name John, but who died in November 20th and was buried at St Denis alongside his father.

The effigy of King John I at St Denis

Image: Pinterest

 Being born as King is a distinction he shares with very few other monarchs, but including King Ladislas V of Hungary in the fifteenth century and King Alfonso XIII of Spain in the nineteenth century.

The rapid demise of King John led at the time to accusations of foul play. Countess Mahaut of Artois, mother-in-law of the Count of Poitiers was alleged to have killed the baby with a needle inserted into his brain. Druon in his novels about the later Capetians has her poisoning the infant, but integrates that with a story that emerged later in the century that the royal child was spirited away and a substitute killed and buried at St Denis. The “real” monarch then reappeared in the 1330s seeking the French crown. Later medieval Europe had a number of such claimants in Norway, England, Denmark and Portugal.

King John I had the shortest reign of any French monarch, unless the claim that King Louis XIX reigned for twenty minutes during the July Revolution in 1830 is accepted. I would be inclined to view that as a situation of duress, and that, in consequence of the Orleanist usurpation King Charles X remained the legitimate monarch until his death in 1836 and that he was then succeeded by King Louis XIX until his death in 1844 and the undoubted inheritance at that point of King Henri V. Wikipedia makes the same point in Louis Antoine, Duke of Angoulême

The death of King John was to be of real significance. For the first time since the election of Hugh Capet in 987 the succession did not pass from father to eldest surviving son. This change was not that obvious if Jeanne was ruled out as both female and possibly illegitimate, although she did become Queen Jeanne II of Navarre in 1328 following the death of her other paternal uncle, King Charles IV.

The acceptance by the political elite of her uncle the Count of Poitiers as King Philip V rather than Jeanne 
took France towards the Salic law, although that was not fully defined until the late fourteenth century. 

There is a Wikipedia biography of King Philip V - the Tall - at Philip V of France

Both he and his brother and successor King Charles IV sought to produce a male heir, but only had daughters, who were now seen as ineligible for the throne. In 1328 the French crown passed to their cousin Philip, Count of Valois who became King Philip VI. This by-passed the arguable claim by proximity of blood of the son of the sister of Kings Louis, Philip and Charles. That was the formidable Queen Isabella, widow ( probably or possibly ) of King Edward II and mother of King Edward III. Possessing a claim to the French crown was a very useful weapon in the young King of England’s diplomatic and military armoury as he sought to disentangle the constraints on his position in both England and Gascony that arose from the implicit alliance of France and Scotland. The argument that the Hundred Years War lasted two centuries and began in 1292 rather than 1337 is a good one. As to when the wars ended maybe we should look to King George III agreeing not to use the title King of France in the Treaty of Amiens in 1802…

Image result for philip V effigy St Denis

The effigies of King Philip V, Queen Jeanne of Evreux, third wife of King Charles IV, and of King Charles IV as now displayed at St Denis 

Image: Pinterest-Basilique de St Denis

For more about these fascinating events in France there are now good history books available and, for really pacy reading, Maurice Druon’s six Accursed Kings novels and the 1973 ORTF television series - not the later remake.

Thursday, 12 November 2026

Martinmas and St Martin’s Lent


Following on from my previous post about St Martin’s church in York I came today upon an article on OnePeterFive about traditional ways of celebrating Martinmas. This is touched upon by the Wikipedia entry I linked to in my last article, but this gives much more detail. Coming from a US based author and website it begins with specifically North American references but then broadens out to look at how the feast was celebrated in the past. It also narrates how this was the beginning of a ‘long’ Advent and the lead up to Christmas for a number of centuries.
  

Before taking temporary leave of St Martin I want to return to the first image of him on his Wikipedia biography.


St Martin
Simone Martini c.1284-1344

Image: Wikipedia 

Can we see in this a fourth century bishop, or an early fourteenth century bishop, and his reaction, were such an event possible in either fourth century Gaul or fourteenth century Avignon, to a Synod on Synodality?

May St Martin pray for us all


Wednesday, 11 November 2026

The St Martin window in Coney Street York


Today is the feast of St Martin of Tours. 

The fourth century bishop became the first non-martyr to be honoured with specific prayers and office hymn, and became the patron of many churches across not only Gaul and the Frankish lands but also the British Isles and much of Europe. One theory is that at least some churches under his patronage were founded by missionaries inspired by his example and that they originated soon after his death in 397.

Wikipedia has a lengthy study of the life and cult of St Martin of above average quality and which has a handsome set of illustrations from over the centuries. It covers a great range of themes and places, and it can be accessed at Martin of Tours

In York, which still has two medieval churches dedicated to St Martin, his enduring appeal into the fifteenth century can be clearly seen in the church of St Martin in Coney Street.


The semi-restored church of St Martin on Coney Street in York

Image:tripadvisor.com

One of oldest foundations amongst the city churches, in the Anglo-Danish era it stood on what was already one of the principal thoroughfares. Coney Street is a corruption of King’s Street. It was apparently rebuilt in stone about 1080 and then altered over succeeding centuries. However it was completely rebuilt in the first half of the fifteenth century. 

The inspiration for this was the vicar Robert Semer, who held the living from 1425 to 1443. I suspect from his name that he came from Seamer near Scarborough, where the parish church is also dedicated to St Martin. Robert may well have already had a devotion to St Martin before he arrived in Coney Street. He gave the west window in honour of St Martin in 1437, and is depicted in a donor panel at the base of the central light. In his will in 1443 he left his money to complete the rebuilding on condition that it was completed within seven years.

The church was where the future St Margaret Clitherow was baptised in 1553, in the still surviving font.

On April 29th 1942 the church was wrecked by a bomb. Fortunately the St Martin window had been removed to ensure its survival, and some other figures in other windows, including a fine St George, survived. In 1968 the ruins were semi-restored in a scheme that has all that post-war British half-heartedness when it came to restoring historic buildings that had suffered in the war. However the glass can be seen at eye level in the chapel created out of the old south aisle, and even in its mutilated state the glass, the south aisle and the elegant tower with their buttresses sprouting pinnacles and the pierced parapet bear abundant witness to the skills of York masons and glaziers in the first half of the fifteenth century.


The St Martin window

Image: Wikimedia 

The St Martin window shows St Martin at the centre, surrounded by scenes, in no particular order, from his life as recorded by Sulpicius Severus.


St Martin drives out a devil and saves a hare from hounds

Image:visitstainedglass.uk - Chris Parkinson



Robert Semer, vicar and benefactor 
His breviary is open at Ps.51
He is not wearing a blue cope but blue is used to indicate his black cappa nigra worn over his almuce

Image:britainexpress.com


May St Martin pray for us all


Tuesday, 10 November 2026

Medieval lead mining in the Peak District


EcoNews has an article based on research published in Antiquity about research into human remains from the Derbyshire Peak District and from Castleton itself which has looked for evidence in teeth of lead as an indicator for the extraction of the metal in the medieval centuries.
 

Peveril Castle above Castleton in 
the Peak District

Image: letsgopeakdistrict.co.uk

The results, of what the investigating teams says is a very restricted sample, from the Anglo-Saxon era through to the High Middle Ages indicate that lead extraction and smelting was well established at the earliest dates in the seventh century. It was to be a consistent feature of the local economy for centuries. Production appears to have peaked around 1200. In the period from the late twelfth century up to the sixteenth century the Peak District was the largest supplier of lead in western Europe.

The skeletons indicate that those who worked closely with the ore ingested much more than did those who lived and died locally who were, apparently, from local elites. The level of lead contamination for some of those thought to have been working with the galena was as high as figures for the early Industrial Revolution.


Some of my ancestors were living in the Peak District by at least the seventeenth century, but whether they were involved in lead mining and processing I do not know.

Sunday, 8 November 2026

St Louis 800


Today is the eighth centenary of the death of King Louis VIII of France, and the accession of his eldest son as King Louis IX. The new king was twelve and his mother, Queen Blanche of Castile, became regent. Three weeks after his accession he was crowned at Reims. In contrast to the three year reign of his father he was to reign for forty four years until his death whilst on Crusade in 1270, and just exceeding the forty three year reign of his grandfather King Philip II. Their two reigns were two of the most consequential for the French monarchy and key to its formation of France as a state. In another respect he outdid his father and grandfather being canonised in 1297, and became a focus of French Catholic and royal devotion.


King Louis IX


Queen Blanche

The two portraits are from the Bible of St Louis
and are dated to 1226-34

Images: Wikimedia Commons

I wrote at length about the Bible of St Louis in an article on this blog to mark his feast day in 2014. Unfortunately many of the illustrations have disappeared but the text is still accessible at St Louis and his Bible

Wikipedia has a useful biography of St Louis which not only gives a biography but also outlines the development of royal administration during his reign. This was in part at least directly inspired by the king himself. It can be read at Louis IX of France


An early fourteenth century polychrome statue 
of St Louis. The colour has faded and the fleurons on the crown have been broken off

Image: Wikimedia Commons


Another view of the statue showing more of the decoration of the royal mantle. Presumably the missing hands carried the royal sceptre and the Hand of Justice. The wry smile is an attractive feature, and indicative of the man described in Joinville’s memoir which was commissioned by King Philip IV

Image: Flickr

Every subsequent King of France has been a direct descendant of St Louis. The Valois dynasty descended from his grandson, the younger brother of King Philip IV in 1328, whilst his great great grandson King Edward III of  England advanced his own Plantagenet claim. In 1589 the crown passed to the descendants of his youngest son, Robert, Count of Clermont, in the House of Bourbon. Through these lines and many marriages St Louis is thus an ancestor of all English monarchs from 1327 and of Scottish monarchs from 1437, of nearly all Portuguese monarchs from 1433, of all the branches of the Bourbons and of the Habsburgs, together with those lines in modern times descended from Queen Victoria and King Christian IX.

His acquisition of the Crown of Thorns brought that relic from the East to Paris and to the shrine church St Louis created for it in the Sainte Chapelle. It is now in the care of Notre Dane de Paris, and was rescued from the devastating fire of a few years ago.
 

The Crown of Thorns 

Image: Wikimedia Commons
  
Of St Louis himself Notre Dame also possesses a remarkable survival, which was also saved from the flames. This is one of the king’s shirts, and has been recorded as such since 1480, and there is no reason to doubt that it is of thirteenth century provenance. Although missing a sleeve it is in good condition and quite moving to see just the other side of the glass in an exhibition case in the cathedral. 

Wikipedia has an article about it at Shirt of Saint Louis. That links to a much more detailed study which can be accessed at Another Look at St. Louis' Shirt


The shirt of St Louis

Image: Wikipedia 

If readers want to know more about the Saint King I would heartily recommend the memoir written by his Crusading companion Jean de Joinville and available in translation from Penguin. 

There are modern biographies by Margaret Wade Labarge and by Jacques Le Goff.


Statue of St Louis dated to 1275-1325 from the Grand Reliquary of the Sainte Chapelle. It is suggested this may be the best near contemporary likeness. There appears to be a family resemblance to the effigy at St Denis of his grandson King Philip IV

Image: Ad Imaginem Dei


May St Louis pray for France, for his descendants and for us all

Friday, 6 November 2026


Today is appointed for the liturgical commemoration of Bl. Salvio Huix Mirelpeix C.O., the Oratorian Bishop of Lleida martyred along with twenty of his clergy in the opening weeks of the Spanish Civil War. I wrote about their deaths on the ninetieth anniversary in August in my article Bl. Salvio Huix Mirelpeix



Bl.Salvio Huix Mirelpeix 

Image: santiebeati.it


I have now found another, illustrated, account of his life and death on a Brazilian website - but with an English translation included - and which can be accessed at Beato Salvio Huix-Miralpeix, Bispo e Mártir

The Mass and Benediction in Bl. Salvio’s honour at the Oxford Oratory was celebrated by Fr Dominic Jacob C.O., who has a longstanding devotion to the martyr. At the conclusion of his homily Fr Dominic told the congregation that the lace decorated alb he was wearing was one which had belonged to Bl.Salvio, and of his sense of the privilege of being able to wear it.


May Bl. Salvio and his fellow martyrs continue to pray for the Spanish Church and Realm, for the Oratorian congregation, and for us all

Wednesday, 4 November 2026

How things have changed…

 
Looking at my Substack feed yesterday I was struck by this post from Alexander Thompson, which can be read below:

How much do you think the average working-class 12-year-old boy read a year in 1940? 

The total is ridiculously enormous. According to Jenkinson’s 1940 study:

48 books for pleasure 
24 books in quiet reading time in school
9-12 books in literature class 
48 “boys magazines” (also known as ‘bloods’)
13 periodical hobby magazines 
26 newspapers 

The 1570 boys studied by Jenkinson read 7371 books a month - and the girls read even more! 

What were they reading? A vast mixture of high and low-brow fiction. Firm favourites included Robinson Crusoe, David Copperfield, Sherlock Holmes, Tom Brown’s Schooldays; Treasure Island; and Gulliver’s Travels. 

I am often reminded of how the past is a foreign country. I can hardly believe these figures, yet Jenkinson did not regard them as particularly impressive. If anything they “needed improvement”. Hence the wholesome reading strategies of the inner-city teacher:

During the first year [of middle school] there is little difficulty. The boys are unsophisticated, avid, joyous in their reading. Moreover, we give them suitable stuff to read – ballads, simple lyrics, the jollier narrative verse (e.g. “Horatius, John Gilpin, the Pied piper, Goblin Market, stories of Greece, Rome, of the Norsemen, of Robin Hood”).


 I shared it with some friends and think it may be of interest to readers of this blog. It was quite an eye-opener to see how the formation of young people has changed, and not, I think, and indeed fear, for the better.

This study antedates the famed 1944 Education Act, let alone the fickle educational policies of successive British governments of all configurations. I know it is before the advent of the restored television service of the1950s, but, alas, television these days has lost the moral seriousness ithad in the 1950s and 1960s, or the quality adaptations of classic books and dramas from the 1970s and 1980s 

The Internet offers so much, but so much therein is bad or just lazy ‘click bait’. 

Reading the post made me all the more grateful for The Queen’s initiatives to get young, and not so young people reading.