The debate on the Reform of the Reform

I recently posted Reform of the Reform or Reversal of the Reform? about part of the current discussion about the way the Roman liturgy might or should develop.

This is, inevitably, very much a continuing debate and here are three recent contributions to it from the New Liturgical Movement site, which give a variety of viewpoints and possible lines of approach.

The Growing Realization of the Irreparable Failure of the Liturgical Reform
by Peter Kwasniewski

Reform of the Reform - Not Impossible
by Ben Yanke and quoting an article by Bishop Peter J. Elliott 

Is the Reform of the Reform Dead? Fr. Christopher Smith's Essay at the Chant Cafe
by Jennifer Donelson

On a related matter, that of the nature of the Offertory, there is an interesting post from the same site which can be read at   

The Theology of the Offertory: A Response to a Recent Article Quoted on PrayTell (Part 1)
by Gregory DiPippo who cites an article by Fr. Anthony Ruff OSB, the editor and principal writer of PrayTell